Now everyone is an insider!
In order to provide an open forum for ALL of the museum’s collection and activities, the Paper + People blog is being renamed SCMA Insider. With its expanded focus, SCMA Insider will act as a go-to place for sharing information on the diverse collections and many voices and visions that shape SCMA.
If you want to contribute to the blog, please contact the Brown Post-Baccalaureate Curatorial Fellow, Shanice Bailey, at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Tuesday, September 29, 2015
Student Picks is a SCMA program in which Smith students organize their own one-day art show using our collection of works on paper. This month’s student curator and guest blogger Yu Yan '18 discusses her show "SHE" which will be on view FRIDAY, October 2 from 12-4 PM in the Cunningham Center for the Study of Prints, Drawings, and Photographs. We hope to see you here!
The reason I picked these photographs is simple and direct: to find different “she”.
How did women evaluate themselves? How did the photographer define the women through the lens? What kind of role was expected to be played by women? And how did women respond to the social expectations that already existed?
Felice Beato, British, born Italy (1825-1904). At her Toilette, ca. 1868. Albumen print with hand coloring mounted on cream colored paperboard. Purchased with the Hillyer-Tryon-Mather Fund, with funds given in memory of Nancy Newhall (Nancy Parker, class of 1930) and in honor of Beaumont Newhall, and with funds given in honor of Ruth Wedgwood Kennedy. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 1982:38-2 (4)
Among these photographs, women are depicted with diverse values and roles, over a really wide range of cultures, time periods, locations, religions and many other social backgrounds. In this exhibition, I set up several groups for these photographs about women, so it will be interesting if you could imagine any connections between two photographs in one group.
Joel Meyerowitz, American (born 1938). NYC Easter, 1984. Vintage chromogenic contact print. Gift of Nicole Moretti Ungar, class of 1982, and Jon Ungar. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 2014:53-57
Wednesday, September 23, 2015
The Book of Hours was a type of Christian prayer text that was extremely common in the Middle Ages. Unlike most of the religious writing being produced during this time, they were intended for private, individual devotion, meant to imitate the structure of monastic hours in a format more easily accessible to lay folk. They could be lavishly illustrated or left unadorned, depending on how wealthy the owner was.
Unknown (French). Illuminated Leaf from book of hours, n.d. Color and gold on vellum. Gift of the estate of Mrs. Charles Lincoln Taylor (Margaret Rand Goldthwait, class of 1921). Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 1994:20-19
The above example would have been taken from a finer edition; the illustration depicts the Adoration of the Magi, wherein three kings pay their respects to Mary and the infant Jesus. While some of the background details are crude, the figures themselves are well-made.
Detail of figures
The kings in particular are lavishly dressed—though their style is certainly more in accordance with medieval fashion than biblical. The crowns, halos, and many of the details on the hair and clothing have been highlighted in shell gold, a kind of paint made by crushing gold leaf in a mixture of water and adhesive. This gives it a wonderfully luminescent quality.
Unknown (French). Single leaf from Book of Hours, ca. 1480. Ink and gold on vellum. Purchased. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 1950:144
One can also see the faint margin lines on the outer edges of this page, providing the scribe and artist (these were usually separate roles) a layout to work within. The words in red ink would have actually been done by a third person, generally known as the rubricator. Rubrics were used to indicate titles, headings, or other important words in the text.
Hardouin, Gillet (published by), French (active 1491 - 1521). Adoration of the Magi (recto); Text with Border (verso), from Livre d'Heures, n.d. Metal cut text with hand illuminated letters in red, blue and gold on parchment. Purchased. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 1950:32
This page from a later book of hours was not hand-lettered, but made using metalcut prints. Still, it uses many of the stylistic conventions found in earlier manuscripts—the elaborate illustrated borders and the hand-painted red and blue initials, for example. By the early 16th century, printed books could be produced faster, in greater numbers, and at a lower cost than their handwritten counterparts, meaning that elaborately illustrated books were no longer limited to the very wealthy.
Adoration of the Magi (recto)
The opposite side of the page also depicts an Adoration of the Magi scene; again, even though the page was made in a completely different way, there are striking similarities between it and the previous image. However, both the architectural border that “frames” the scene and the image itself are much more detailed, even crowded.
What is fascinating about Books of Hours is that they were so incredibly adaptable to their audience. Christian worship in the medieval era was institutional, dominated by the clergy and monasteries. The Bible itself was written and spoken only in Latin, rendering it inaccessible to ordinary people without the mediation of a priest. Since religious worship was so important to people of every class, the books reveal as much about their owners as they do their contents.
Tuesday, September 15, 2015
Guest blogger Saraphina Masters is a Smith College student, class of 2017, majoring in Classical Studies and Art History. She was the 2013-2015 STRIDE Scholar in the Cunningham Center for Prints, Drawings, and Photographs.
Martha Wilson is regarded as one of the pioneering feminist artists of her time, and rightly so. Working in multi-media that prominently features digital work, Wilson has spent the greater part of her career exploring the female body and what it is to be feminine within the confines of society. She studied and taught in Halifax, Nova Scotia before moving to New York to be more expressive as a young, female artist. Wilson’s origins are in textual and language based art, and though she is best known for her physical, performance art, the presence of the written word is still visible and relevant. This potent combination can be seen in her work entitled A Portfolio of Models. This collection of six images, each with their own accompanying text, is prefaced by a separate written introduction that reads:
“These are the models society holds out to me: Goddess, Housewife, Working Girl, Professional, Earth Mother, Lesbian. At one time or another, I have tried them all on for size, and none has fit. All that’s left to do is be an artist and point the finger at my own predicament. The artist operates out of the vacuum left when all other values are rejected.”
— Martha Wilson, August 1974
Martha Wilson, American (born 1947). Title and Text from A Portfolio of Models, 1974-2008. Gelatin silver print with typewritten text. Purchased with the Dorothy C. Miller, class of 1925, Fund. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 2011:27-1
In her series of six photographs, Wilson portrays six separate women, all of whom exist in highly disparate spheres of society and are presented as the six archetypes of femininity. As she is the only model, Wilson modifies her appearance in order to cast herself as each character. Clothing, hair, and makeup, as well as pose and posture, all comprise the woman whom Wilson is meant to represent. The miniature character analysis that is paired with each image examines the women in relation to their place in society, their intelligence, and their sexuality.
Martha Wilson, American (born 1947). The Goddess from A Portfolio of Models, 1974-2008. Gelatin silver print with typewritten text. Purchased with the Dorothy C. Miller, class of 1925, Fund. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 2011:27-2
One fascinating aspect of these women and their textual biographies is that each woman’s paragraph relates her in some aspect to the first woman depicted: the Goddess. The Goddess is presented as the perfect woman: relevant and attractive to all members of society. Wilson casts herself as the Goddess by wearing a silk suit that emulates quality and striking in a dramatic, sensual pose with an impassive look on her face. Her appearance and even smell is perfect, and though she is attractive, she is too far removed from reality and thus asexual. Interestingly, Wilson states clearly that the Goddess is “an implicit image of reference”. The other portraits in this series support that statement in that the Goddess is mentioned in all following descriptions and exists as a constant model to be imitated.
Martha Wilson, American (born 1947). The Housewife from A Portfolio of Models, 1974-2008. Gelatin silver print with typewritten text. Purchased with the Dorothy C. Miller, class of 1925, Fund. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 2011:27-3
The Housewife is, physically at least, the opposite of the Goddess. Conservative clothing, a poised stance, and a frozen smile paired with a cup of coffee give the impression that this is a woman who expresses few of her true emotions. Wilson notes that the Housewife “is intelligent, but has convinced herself that she is fulfilled.” This could be a commentary on the sacrifices that Wilson perceives full time mothers and wives to be constantly making. The Housewife aspires to be like the Goddess, but the realities and practicalities of her everyday life, such as feeding her children, limit her.
Martha Wilson, American (born 1947). The Working Girl from A Portfolio of Models, 1974-2008. Gelatin silver print with typewritten text. Purchased with the Dorothy C. Miller, class of 1925, Fund. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 2011:27-4
The Working Girl is another departure from the ever-present standard of the Goddess. To portray her, Wilson wears a short skirt and low floral blouse that, paired with a tall wig and a loose high-heeled shoe, characterizes the Working Girl as lower-class and less refined. The artist both implies visually and states textually that this woman is barred from the ideal of the Goddess by her budget. Her intelligence is questionable and her work ethic, though admirable, will never earn her credit or praise. The woman that Wilson presents here is evokes pity as well as resignation.
Martha Wilson, American (born 1947). The Professional from A Portfolio of Models, 1974-2008. Gelatin silver print with typewritten text. Purchased with the Dorothy C. Miller, class of 1925, Fund. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 2011:27-5
Wilson represents the Professional with a somber expression that matches the dark color of her masculine pants suit. Her hat hides her hair and the posture of her body on the tall chair indicates confidence and nonchalance. This is a woman who actively participates in the professional world, but according to Wilson, “plays down her competence to get along.” In saying this, Wilson is addressing the place of women in the workforce and the adjustments they must make in order to fit with society and its expectations of them. The Professional contrasts the Working Girl in that the high price of her outfit is the only way she relates to the Goddess. The sexuality of the Professional is questionable in this presentation; it may be her job that fulfils her or she may do her job because she is unfulfilled.
Martha Wilson, American (born 1947). The Earth Mother from A Portfolio of Models, 1974-2008. Gelatin silver print with typewritten text. Purchased with the Dorothy C. Miller, class of 1925, Fund. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 2011:27-6
The Earth-Mother, both physically and mentally, is the “perfect mirror-reversal” the Goddess. Wilson wears a long, loose-fitting floral dress and a white head scarf, indicating that appearances are not important to this type of woman. Wilson believes that such pointed contrariness from the Goddess is indicative of the Earth-Mother’s hyper-consciousness of that refined role model. She casually regards her sexuality as natural and inherent and her intellect is secondary to her connection to physical labor and the land.
Martha Wilson, American (born 1947). The Lesbian from A Portfolio of Models, 1974-2008. Gelatin silver print with typewritten text. Purchased with the Dorothy C. Miller, class of 1925, Fund. Photography by Petegorsky/Gipe. SC 2011:27-7
The Lesbian is, according to Wilson, the ultimate foil to the Goddess. Wilson as the Lesbian wears chunky boots, a jacket and a firm stance paired with a contrary tilt of the head. This woman perceives and scorns the Goddess as an invention of commercial male minds and “she alone see through goddessdom.” However, the Lesbian’s sexuality deviates from societal norms and thus excludes her from perception and discourse. Likewise, her intelligence is surpasses by her emotional issues. As is the case with all of Wilson’s other women, the Lesbian is reduced to a single defining quality.
Created during the second wave of feminism, A Portfolio of Models physically explores the ways in which women are characterized and defined by society. Martha Wilson uses her own body, transformed with the aid of clothing, styling, and body language, to examine six distinct types of women whom she presents to the viewer both visually and textually. These women are all related to each other and particularly to the Goddess model, whom Wilson casts as the ultimate women. In presenting such clean cut divisions within the female gender, this series creates a space for the viewer to think critically about themselves, women they know (or don’t) and even Wilson herself as a woman and an artist. Wilson declares that she has removed herself from any of these archetypes by becoming an artist and thus exists in the empty space that she created by rejecting these six basic models.
Phenomenal art is marked by its continued relevance and if it provokes thought long after its initial debut. To this day, A Portfolio of Models brings up a great deal of questions, such as how these roles exist then as well as today, and are modern women a part of them? Wilson invites you to examine the six women she became and consider how they relate to you.